Skip to main content

Hot Take: Preowned + Vintage are the Greenest

I applaud the effort by watch manufacturers to minimize their contributions to climate change. Globally, we've made some progress towards "bending the curve" of greenhouse gas emissions, which is the good news.
This figure from shows that, even under an optimistic scenario, some increase in global temperatures is unavoidable.
The bad news is that we clearly need to do a whole lot more to get to a point where we halt the growing cost of environmental degradation. As the graph I've presented here shows, existing policies are not enough to ensure a healthy planet for our children, their children, and all future generations.

As Elizabeth Doer's outstanding coverage on Quill and Pad shows, the watch industry is discussing the challenges ahead and developing contributions to the fight against climate change. These include the use of recycled and recovered materials in manufacturing as well as requiring transparency in how raw materials are sourced.

We like to imagine that the simple act of buying a traditional mechanical watch is good for the environment. Supposedly, a traditional mechanical watch lasts a long time and it is not "disposable." This is a reasonable point. However, when it comes to information, collectors and buyers will struggle to learn the exact environmental impact of any particular watch purchase.
A WWF assesment of watch brand environmental friendliness.
The image here comes from a 2018 WWF report on the jewelry and watch industry. The report author rated the majority of watch brands as "latecomers" and "non-transparent."

When we turn to the Apple Watch, a supposedly "disposable" bit of kit, we discover that Apple is actually ahead of most of the luxury watch industry when it comes to disclosure. On their web page, after a fair bit of digging, you can find a report offering carbon footprint figures for the Apple watch, calculated according to an international set of standards (ISO 14040 and 14044). I tried to find similar environmental disclosure statements for major Swiss watch brands and I got nowhere (although this Rolex infographic by some undergraduates is pretty cool and interesting). I do believe it is still likely that a Swiss mechanical watch is more environmentally friendly than a smartwatch. For example, a smartwatch requires electricity, the production of which almost always casts off greenhouse gases. A mechanical watch involves converting caloric intake into stored energy through a wound spring. That caloric energy is either recovered as you move about (automatic winding) or you "exert" yourself to wind the watch. In either case, my guess is that the greenhouse gas emissions from winding a mainspring is negligible compared to the energy used in charging an Apple Watch.

But why am I left to guess about this? If I really do care about the future of the planet and I want to compare the carbon footprint of a mechanical watch to an Apple Watch, why is the traditional watch industry making it so hard to do so? Fortunately, every collector has a readymade solution to this conundrum: buy preowned or vintage. Such watches do not require mining or shipping about of raw materials. They don't require consumption of energy in a manufacture in order to create the timepiece. That energy use took place at some point in the past. Therefore, the carbon footprint for a preowned or vintage watch is necessarily lower than the footprint for a brand new watch walking straight out of an authorized dealer's door. Prefer an untouched case? Consider buying a watch from a manufacturer who upcycles components, such as watchmaker Colin de Tonnac at Semper & Adhuc. At least then you'll reduce the environmental impact of a watch that is mostly new.

I have bought my own fair share of brand new watches. However, I have also bought preowned. Since buying a "used" watch is almost certainly better for the environment, I generally feel better about my "secondhand" purchases. Going forward, knowing that the preowned path is greener may well shape my buying patterns.
My book on the history of Rolex marketing is now available on Amazon! It debuted as the #1 New Release in its category. You can find it here.

You can subscribe to Horolonomics updates here.


  1. When we purchase preowned or vintage goods, we are essentially extending the lifespan of these items. This means fewer new items need to be produced, leading to a reduction in the waste generated by manufacturing, packaging, and transportation.This is a good things and this beneficial to the people.If some one have interested to buy mba dissertation help service,so feel free to contact with me.I will give you the best solution.

  2. It's fascinating how Apple's environmental transparency sets them apart in the watch world. However, the comparison of smartwatches and mechanical watches in terms of environmental impact is fascinating. but currently I am busy with my assignment and I am looking for a kfc swot analysis. If someone knows my subject well, please guide me professionally.

  3. Good day I am so excited I found your webpage, I really found you by mistake, while I was looking on Google for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say many thanks for a fantastic post and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to look Kingdom Hearts Organization 13 Black Coat over it all at the moment but I have bookmarked it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the great job.

  4. CBD Oil for Pets popularity has many dog owners turning to it as an alternative treatment. Of course, you want to do everything you can to help your pet.

  5. Excellent post about Greenhouse gas emissions. However, telemedicine in florida is a great way to seek medical health. However, we need fit physical and mental health.

  6. Telepathic communication
    , is a fascinating concept that has captured the imagination of many throughout history. While often portrayed in science fiction and fantasy, the idea of being able to communicate directly with another person's mind sparks curiosity and wonder.

  7. Absolutely! Opting for preowned and vintage items isn't just eco-friendly; it's also a style statement. Have you considered exploring thrift stores or online platforms? Plus, it's budget-friendly! Speaking of which, if you need academic assistance, I recommend finding the best assignment writer uk to ensure top-notch quality.

  8. While the discussion around preowned and vintage items emphasizes sustainability, let's not overlook the environmental impact of our infrastructure choices. In Karachi, where sustainability is gaining traction, the best diesel generator companies karachi,play a crucial role in minimizing ecological footprints.

  9. The East Lift has been an absolute game-changer! Its efficiency and reliability have truly transformed our daily operations. From the seamless transport of goods to the swift movement of personnel, this lift has become an indispensable asset in our workspace. Kudos to the team behind its design and implementation!

  10. CubePeaks is an innovative platform that brings together the best of adventure and community. With its unique approach to virtual exploration, CubePeaks offers users an immersive experience that transcends boundaries. Whether you're scaling virtual peaks or connecting with like-minded adventurers, CubePeaks is the ultimate destination for those seeking thrills and camaraderie in equal measure.

  11. Analyzing the Nifty spot today feels like deciphering the intricate colors of a pencil sketch. Each subtle shift in trend and volatility adds a new hue to the canvas of market dynamics. As traders, we must blend our technical expertise with an artist's intuition to sketch out profitable strategies amidst this colorful tapestry of price action.

  12. Kulsoom Hina's dedication toNew York charities is truly commendable. Her tireless efforts and unwavering commitment to making a positive impact in our community are inspiring. Through her involvement with various charitable organizations in New York, she exemplifies the spirit of giving back and creating meaningful change. Her contributions not only uplift those in need but also serve as a beacon of hope for a brighter future. Thank you, Kulsoom Hina, for your selfless service and dedication to making New York a better place for all.

  13. A provides expertise that helps businesses optimize their customer relationship management systems. Just as preowned and vintage items contribute to a greener planet by reducing waste, a Dynamics CRM consultant helps businesses streamline processes, enhance customer engagement, and improve overall efficiency, leading to sustainable growth.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Argon Trademark Dispute Goes to Court

What it might look like if Aragon and Argon watches actually went to court over the trademark dispute. My prior post described a disappointing development for those collectors hoping to acquire an Argon Spaceone watch via the brand's Kickstarter campaign. The campaign had reached over $1 million in funding when Kickstarter's management stepped in and froze the whole thing over an "intellectual property dispute." When I posted about this development on Instagram , Hodinkee editor Tony Traina noted in the comments that another brand, Aragon watches, had filed a complaint with the US Patent and Trade Office (USPTO) back in April (thanks Tony!). Argon's account replied and indicated that they had already filed a registration for their brand name and they were retaining counsel in New York City. On Tuesday, June 27 of this week, more details were offered via a lawsuit filed in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida. The case is filed on behalf

In-House Means In Control

Among many avid watch collectors, the term "in house movement" seems to elicit eyerolling disdain. Pieces of an assortment, including balance spring, from a non-Swiss movement. There is a sizeable perception that "in house" is, in fact, nothing more than an unnecessary marketing ploy designed to tease more money out of the wallet of buyers (by way of definition, an "in house" movement means that the mechanism inside a watch was predominently manufactured by a brand itself, kind of like "we make our own bread" at a restaurant). I'll confess that I'd begun to think similarly, that is, until I read a 66 page report posted by the Swiss Competition Commision on May 10, 2023. Yes, this is the kind of thing an economist finds interesting on a weekend, or at least this economist. Before we get into the details of this report, in the interest of full disclosure I should say that the original document was in a different language: lawyerese.

Has Swatch Encountered Diminishing Returns?

They say a picture is worth a thousand words, but I'm not sure it is worth a thousand points of data. My Mission to Mars MoonSwatch and Fifty Fathoms homage by Steeldive. The pictures from the last 10 days or so suggest that Swatch has delivered another blockbuster by way of their most recent "collaboration" with Blancpain, this one officially known as the Bioceramic Scuba Fifty Fathoms (SFF). Social media served up numerous photos of queues outside of Swatch stores ahead of the SFF launch on September 9. Plenty of aspiring owners waited long hours for their chance to buy the newest accessible riff on a design that typically commands a price in the five digit range. I'll admit that the photos convinced me that Swatch has a replicable formula for developing watches that are so in demand they can be flipped for a sizable premium. As I've done before, though, I prefer to ask the data what, exactly, is going on with the release of this timepiece. And the data